Skip to main content

Concrete vs. Asphalt: Pros and Cons

As a homeowner, you may be wondering concrete vs. asphalt, is there a difference? And if so, which one is a better choice for my driveway? While concrete and asphalt perform the same function, there are some key differences between them.

Sand and stone make up both materials, but different adhesives hold them together. Concrete uses cement and asphalt uses a petroleum-based mix. Each is a popular material for driveways and you can’t go wrong with either one. Factors such as weather, budget, and personal aesthetics often influence which material homeowners choose. Keep reading to discover which material is the best fit for you!

Benefits of Concrete


Concrete can last upwards of 40 years, while asphalt usually lasts 20-30. Keep in mind that proper care and maintenance are important for both materials.


Concrete comes in different colors, stains, and finishes. If you don’t want that typical dark black look of asphalt, concrete may be a better option.

Sealing Not Required

Concrete does not require sealing, but we do suggest it. We recommend you apply a sealing treatment every 5 years, as opposed to every 3-5 years with asphalt.

Cons of Concrete

Cold Weather Preparation

Cold weather, snow, and ice can wreak havoc on your concrete. To prevent cracking and degradation you’ll need to prep your concrete and maintain it during the winter months.

Difficult to Repair

As opposed to asphalt, it is pretty difficult to repair concrete. So unless you plan on resurfacing your driveway, cracks and damages can look evident.

Shows Marks & Spills

Unfortunately, due to its light coloring, concrete shows stains & spill marks.

Benefits of Asphalt

Performs Better in Cold Weather

Concrete can buckle and crack if not prepared for cold weather conditions. Asphalt holds up fine in cold weather and even helps snow and ice melt faster.

Easy to Repair

Unlike concrete, you can perform quick patch repairs on asphalt. You can also apply a new top coat to cover up wear and tear.

Hides Stains

Concerned about staining or spill ruining the look of your driveway? Consider choosing asphalt as its dark color hides stains and marks.

Cons of Asphalt

Requires Sealing

While concrete sealing is optional, asphalt requires an initial sealing treatment and then one every 3-5 years. Sealing isn’t hard for homeowners to do themselves, but it is something to be mindful of.

Doesn’t Perform Well in Heat

In high heat conditions, asphalt can turn sticky and even melt. If you live in a warm climate, this could be a deal breaker.

Frequent Repairs

Because asphalt is not as durable as concrete, it will end up needing more repairs. Increased maintenance is an important factor to consider.

What is Cheaper Concrete or Asphalt?

Here comes the question most homeowners are wondering! Which material is going to be more cost-effective? Concrete is the more expensive option, usually costing $3-10 per square foot. Asphalt comes in around $2-5 per square foot. Longevity & durability are also important aspects to consider when factoring in costs.

Closing Thoughts

Whether concrete or asphalt is better, depends on a homeowner’s situation. Overall your budget and location’s climate will be the biggest deciding factors. But it all comes down to personal preference! With the right installation and maintenance, you can enjoy an attractive and functioning driveway for years to come.

Concrete Driveway Company Near Me

Trust NYS Enterprises with your asphalt and concrete needs in the Seattle Area. A new driveway is a big investment, so don’t hesitate to contact us for more information!

Contact NYS Enterprises

Contact NYS today to learn more about our commercial asphalt services in the Seattle area.

Get Started

We don’t just take care of your asphalt- we take care of you.